Liz Shinouda Memories Banner

Home

Memories

Links

Contact Us

Photos

Still Among Us

Margaret


Gazebo Button
New Paltz

Marilyn Rosenberg
 
Dear Marguerite Liz and Kids in Indiana
 
We just returned from a wedding in Toronto which we extended into a short  vacation in Montreal , and so I just  became aware of  your mother’s passing.   I was shocked and so sad to learn that she had died in April.  I know how much she loved you and  the loss must be inexplicable.  The death of a parent leaves an incredible hole in the world.  Its hard for me to believe that she has died.
 
Your mom and I shared a difficult time together.  Beginning teachers have so much to deal with and this was the time of the Vietnam War,  which I think had an affect on even our middle school students- longhair, drugs and general rebelliousness.  Your mom and I would talk for long periods of time after school.   With great wisdom she decided that work in a library would  be a much better fit for her., and clearly from your note that was a wise choice on her part.  Elizabeth had so much to offer the world , and  I’m glad she found a place where she could be most appreciated. 
 
In some of our after school talks , your mom, being the observer, she was, would talk  about the differences between life in the Midwest and in the East, and I had never known anyone from the Midwest, so I listened eagerly.   “Everyone speaks so quickly here”, she said.  I had never noticed but clearly she was right and I learned to slow down as we spoke. Elizabeth always had such a measured cadence in her speech.  She would pause and really think about her responses .     We laughed, at some of her other observations, which have stayed with me over the years.  She became aware of how we pronounced words differently in the East.    One day she came into my room after school and wrote  Mary, merry and marry on the board asking me to pronounce each word. I did and she,” aha”, that’s what I thought . She then proceeded to show me that when she said all three words they all sounded like “merry”., another difference between the east and Midwest.  Although we’d laugh at these differences,  I was never sure that Elizabeth , or at least in the time I knew her, was comfortable  living in the East, yet she was very insightful in describing the limitations of Midwestern life.  I had hoped that her change in profession and proximity to her sister would  help her feel more rooted.
   
She was wonderful in holding secrets and  we shared our deepest secrets and worries.  At the time I was trying to conceive my first child and Elizabeth was a tremendous support.  I remember, in fact, both you and your mom visiting after Lauren was born.  When she met my dog who was a “crazy” but loved German shepherd.  She asked in such a solid “Midwestern “ practicality.  “Why would anyone want to have a dog who required so much work.  Dogs are meant to fit into your home and if not …  She was just so matter of fact in her advice.
 
Perhaps my most meaningful interaction with Elizabeth, came one evening  after she had completed the EST training.   Today I believe its  called Landmark Forum .  She came for dinner and she seemed totally transformed.  Her eyes glowed and she seemed to be high on life and possibilities.  We had a lovely evening , and from that experience of Elizabeth , Eddie, my husband, decided to take the EST training as well.  Years later, I also took it and eventually  it gave me the courage to start a path that would lead me to the career I had always wanted.
 
Dear Marguerite, as you know already, your mom  was a totally honest, unaffected, intelligent being who  cared deeply about you and the family.  I can’t believe that 35 or more years have passed since I saw her last.  She touched my life with her wit,  intelligence and her willingness to probe any topic.. 
 
I extend my deepest sympathy to you and your family on her passing.  Next week my family, my daughter, Lauren , her husband and my grandchild  will be at the house for the weekend along with my son, Steven and my son, Adam and his girlfriend, Cara, so I will not be able to attend the memorial service.  From your letter, it seems as if you are in the New Paltz area, perhaps we could arrange a time to chat.
 
In sadness and love
Marilyn
 


Corinne D’Andrea
April 22, 2010


Meg and Liz at AwostinMarguerite,

I'm so sorry that this happened to one of the nicest people I've ever known.  I can honestly say I never heard a negative word about anyone from your Mom.  I know life wasn't always easy for your Mom but nothing ever changed her gentle, sweet disposition.  Except for our September gatherings I haven't seen a lot of her in the last few years but the times that I did see her it was like she'd never left.  She was indeed a special lady and I'm sure she will have a special place wherever she is now.  It was a privilege to have known her and our thought and wishes go out to you as I'm sure you will miss her tremendously.  Remember always the good times as I'm sure that is what she would like you to remember. 

Much love,
Corinne (& Art too) 


Ginny (Weinman) Leitner
April 22, 2010

 
Marguerite,

I am so saddened by the news of your Mom.

When I think of your Mom, the image comes to me of one of the sweetest, most pleasant faces I've ever known and had the privilege of seeing almost every day of my youth. I will never forget the sound of her heart-warming, hearty laugh.

I can't imagine the pain that must be in your heart right now, only slightly comforted by the knowledge that she has no suffering or pain.

My heart goes out to you and your aunt (please forward this to her as well)

With much love-
Ginny
 
 



 
I Did Not Die


 
Do not stand at my grave and forever weep.
I am not there; I do not sleep.
I am a thousand winds that blow.
I am the diamond glints on snow.
I am the sunlight on ripened grain.
I am the gentle autumn’s rain.
When you awaken in the morning’s hush
I am the swift uplifting rush
Of quiet birds in circled flight.
I am the soft stars that shine at night.
Do not stand at my grave and forever cry.
I am not there. I did not die.

Melinda Sue Pacho

 
 


Monika Kretschmar

Dear Marguerite,

As you know I won't be at your mom's service, because we'll be at a wedding at the same time. Life is weird that way, presenting us with a potpourri of events and emotions at the same time. However, while being at the wedding I'll be very aware of your service and will be trying to make a connection to your mom in my mind. Spending this hour with her before her passing was powerful and will forever be one of my precious memories.

With much love,
Monika


Jim Kent
Liz at Awosting

Dear Meg,

I was very sorry to hear about your mom’s passing.  She was very courageous, and so were you, and I’m sorry you couldn’t have had a happier outcome.

We exchanged letters a few months ago, and I know she was keeping up with my situation.  I found it remarkable and touching that she could worry about me with so much of her own situation to think about.  The fact that she did this, of course, explains a lot about you too.

I wish I had magic, to make everything better, but there isn’t any.  We’re all thinking of you and praying for you and with you.

Love,
Jim Kent



Card From Rebecca Masters and Family

               Card from Rebecca Masters 


Corinne D’Andrea
Reunion with Ray and Annette
 
Liz was, above all, a sweet, soft-spoken and gentle lady.  Someone I could go to with a problem and someone who never had an unkind word to say about anyone.  Liz always thought carefully before speaking, but when words emerged they were always meaningful.
 
Liz was my friend and neighbor for many years.  When Liz moved from Nepale Drive I didn’t see much of her due to the fact that she no longer lived in the area.  However, she appeared again when we opened Mountain Meadows Bed & Breakfast, and when I saw her it was like she had never left.
 
Liz’s family meant a great deal to her and she would organize these annual family get togethers for Labor Day Weekend and it was there that I saw a new side of Liz.  I discovered she was a fierce competitor in one area and that was when she played croquet.  In fact her whole family played a mean game of croquet into the wee hours of morning.  In fact special lights would have to be installed on our roof each year for this event.  It was great fun listening to them having such a good time.
 
It was a privilege to have known Liz and I will miss her kind spirit and her friendship.


Elaine Cerillo
 
Dear Marguerite,
 
I am so sorry for your great loss.  Your mom was an amazing woman and lives in you.  She will be your beacon of hope and journeys with you still.
 
Love & Sympathy,
Elaine Cerillo